Shirleys True Value Hardware

At Shirleys True Value Hardware, we’re your trusted partner in bringing your home improvement dreams to life. Our experts can find everything they need for large-scale projects at our one-stop shop.

Our Services

Computer Color-Matching Machine

Our state-of-the-art machine precisely matches a sample to our extensive collection and eliminates the guesswork in paint selection.

Paint Color Matching

Our experienced staff meticulously matches your desired paint color, ensuring a perfect match for your project.

Duplicate Keys

Make copies of your keys quickly and conveniently while you shop with our on-site essential duplication service.

Get a Quote For Your Project

Prices and program participation may vary. Prices are subject to change without notice.

Proudly serving the island of Martha’s Vineyard

At Shirley’s True Value Hardware, we’re more than just a local hardware store. We’re your trusted partner in home improvement projects in Vineyard Haven. As a proud member of the True Value family, we bring decades of expertise and a commitment to serving our community. Whether you’re a seasoned pro or a DIY enthusiast tackling your first project, our knowledgeable staff is here to offer personalized advice.

We provide you with quality tools and essential products for all your home improvement needs. Our services include precise computer color-matching, expert paint color matching, and convenient duplicate key making.

Take advantage of our specialized services for your unique home improvement needs.

Senior Citizen Discount: We offer seniors an exclusive discount on select products and services. This ensures you get the best value while enjoying top-notch customer service and expert advice.

Special Orders: With our exceptional service, you can access a wide range of products tailored to your requirements, ensuring you have everything you need to complete your project successfully.

Window Shades Cut: If you want to update your home decor, our experienced team will ensure your window shades are cut to precise measurements for a seamless installation. You can customize your window treatments to suit your specific style and specifications.

Our Products

At Shirleys True Value Hardware, we’re proud to offer an extensive range of competitively priced products for your home improvement needs. We have everything you need to bring your vision to life, from essential hardware supplies to specialty tools.

Learn More

  • Bird Feed & Supplies
  • Christmas & Holiday Decorations
  • Cleaning Supplies
  • Pet Supplies
  • Grills & Accessories
  • Hand Tools
  • Power Tools
  • Hardware
  • Housewares
  • Lawn & Garden
  • Electrical
  • Patio Furniture
  • Plumbing

For more information call us

(508) 693-3070

Visit Our Store

Shirleys True Value Hardware is independently owned and operated. We provide the support and resources you need to succeed. Visit us today, and let us help you tackle your next project.

Client Testimonials

Our Brands

  • 3M
  • Ames
  • Bona
  • Duracell
  • EasyCare Paint
  • Energizer
  • GE Lighting
  • Greenthumb
  • Holiday Wonderland
  • Ball
  • Kaytee
  • First Alert
  • Krylon
  • Kwikset
  • Louisville Ladder
  • Master Lock
  • Minwax
  • Miracle-Gro
  • Rubbermaid
  • Schlage
  • Scotts
  • Sterilite
  • Ivy Classic